The following is an installment in Crowell & Moring’s Bid Protest Sustain of the Month Series. In this series, Crowell’s Government Contracts Practice keeps you up to date with a summary of one of the most notable bid protest sustain decisions each month. Below, Crowell Consultant (and former GAO Bid Protest Hearing Officer), Cherie Owen, discusses GAO’s decision in Michael Baker-International Stantec JV, where the agency penalized a firm for failing to demonstrate a particular type of experience project even though the solicitation never required it and the agency’s own Q&A disclaimed such a preference.
In Michael Baker-International Stantec JV, B-424641, B-424641.2, Oct. 16, 2026, the Army Corps of Engineers sought architect-engineer services for projects within its Northwestern Division. The procurement contemplated approximately five indefinite-delivery, indefinite-quantity contracts with a shared capacity of $200 million. The solicitation stated that the agency would evaluate firms’ qualifications under five criteria, with the “specialized experience and technical competence” criterion identified as the most important. Of sixteen firms submitting qualifications statements, the agency selected seven to continue to the next phase. Michael Baker ranked tenth and was eliminated from consideration. Michael Baker protested its exclusion.
Under the experience criterion, the solicitation directed firms to submit up to ten completed projects demonstrating their experience and technical competence across a broad scope of anticipated work. That scope included horizontal and vertical construction, new construction, renovation, and maintenance. The solicitation identified specific types of experience firms should address and advised that projects more similar to the requirement in size, complexity, and scope would receive more credit. However, the listed experience categories did not identify design-bid-build (DBB) projects generally, much less require a DBB project involving new construction of a single vertical facility.
The solicitation’s Q&As reinforced that flexibility. Asked whether it preferred a particular project delivery method or would favor DBB/full-design projects over design-build projects, the agency answered: “There is not a preference.” Instead, the agency would focus on a firm’s ability to execute all work types identified in the synopsis. Similarly, when asked about a preferred number of vertical and horizontal projects, the agency responded that “selection of the projects is up to the Offeror.” Overall, the Q&A responses reflected that offerors were to demonstrate breadth of capability, not a prescribed mix of project examples.
Nevertheless, the agency assigned Michael Baker a weakness because a “traditional DBB of a new construction vertical facility was not included” among its ten projects. Michael Baker protested this weakness arguing that it was inconsistent with the solicitation. In resolving the protest, GAO noted that Michael Baker did not lack DBB experience altogether. The agency had acknowledged that three of Michael Baker’s projects demonstrated DBB performance, including a vertical-construction dormitory renovation and two campus-wide designs involving vertical and horizontal construction. The evaluators also credited Michael Baker with a strength for significant technical competence across diverse military projects and a broad range of services. Yet the agency faulted Michael Baker for not devoting one example to DBB design for a single, newly constructed building.
In defending the weakness, the agency argued that firms should have expected to demonstrate the broadest scope of services, including new construction under a DBB delivery method. It also asserted that designing a single new vertical facility was “one of the more likely types of design that might be requested.” GAO was not persuaded. In sustaining the protest, GAO noted that the Corps never explained why DBB design for a single building was meaningfully different from the same type of vertical design performed as part of a larger project that also included horizontal construction. Adding horizontal work did not, without explanation, negate the comparability of the vertical-design experience.
GAO emphasized that agencies may consider matters not expressly stated in a solicitation only where those considerations are reasonably and logically encompassed within the stated criteria, with a clear nexus between the two. Here, nothing reasonably notified firms that at least one project had to combine DBB delivery, new construction, and a single building. The agency’s rigid requirement for this specific type of experience was particularly untenable given the Corps’ express assurances in the Q&A that it had no delivery-method preference and would not mandate demonstration of vertical versus horizontal projects. As a result, GAO found the weakness inconsistent with the solicitation.
Finally, the Corps argued that Michael Baker was unable to demonstrate prejudice because it was ranked tenth. However, GAO noted that the seventh-ranked firm had identical adjectival ratings except under the experience criterion, where it received “exceptional” rather than Michael Baker’s “above average.” GAO could not rule out the possibility that removing the improper weakness would improve Michael Baker’s rating or place it on equal footing with a firm that had been allowed to proceed to the next phase. Noting that doubts about prejudice are resolved in a protester’s favor, GAO sustained the protest and recommended reevaluating its experience and making a new ranking of the most highly qualified firms.
The Michael Baker decision provides an important reminder that, while agencies have broad discretion in setting the rules for a procurement, once those rules are established, the agency must follow them.

















